Style guide

Best Neapolitan Pizza

A ranked guide to Neapolitan entries across The Slice Index.

40 entries · 32 open · 7 closed/archive

What defines this list

Neapolitan is strongest in Cincinnati, Columbus, New York. The page groups the style across cities so the best examples are not trapped inside one local list.

Top examples include Middle Brow, L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele, Paulie Gee’s. The ranking is crust-first: bake, structure, sauce, cheese, and repeatability matter more than reputation.

23 entries have full review text. Score-only records remain in the index but are less editorially developed.

#1
Middle Brow

Middle Brow

Chicago · Logan Square · Neapolitan

9.7Top Tier

The best pizza in America? It might be… It could be… This 2024 James Beard semifinalist serves sourdough-based Neapolitan pizza from a relaxed space off Mozart Street. Rather than a 1000-degree wood-fired oven, their pi…

#2
L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

Italy · Florence · Neapolitan

9.5Top Tier

I sometimes say: the US has the most innovative chefs but not necessarily the best tomatoes*. Italy has the best tomatoes. So, an Italian pizzeria on top of their game is tough to beat. “Michael’s Ancient Pizzeria” is a…

#3
Paulie Gee’s

Paulie Gee’s

Columbus · Neapolitan

9.2Top Tier

I have long been a fan of Paul Giannone (“Paulie Gee”), who in 2010 gave up his office job to pursue his dream of opening a top tier pizzeria. In this he was quite successful & the original Paulie Gee’s in Greenpoint, Br…

#4
L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

New York · West Village · Neapolitan

9.0Top Tier

“The Ancient Pizzeria of Michele” is a NYC outpost of the famous pizzeria in old Naples. The original was founded in 1870, shortly after Italian Unification and decades before the first American pizzeria (@lombardis_pizz…

#5
Rossville Pizza Company

Rossville Pizza Company

Cincinnati · Hamilton · Neapolitan

9.0Top Tier

We recently stopped by the soft-opening of @steelcitypizzaohio (the original location is in Middletown - the “Steel City” itself). The Hamilton outpost sits in the shadow of an old train bridge that evokes strong Roman a…

#6
Little Hill Pizza

Little Hill Pizza

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.9Great

Named for El Cerrito (‘the Little Hill’) this is another local pizza pop-up - Cincy Pizza Pop-ups being a really dynamic space recently. @littlehillpizza frequently appears at @westsidebrewing and @listermannbrewing; We …

#7
Brewer’s Fork

Brewer’s Fork

Boston · Charlestown · Neapolitan

8.8Great

The best pizza in Boston? For my last Boston review, I wanted to try a true New England style pizza. So I grabbed the Spicy Clam to go from Brewer’s Fork in Charlestown. New England is clam country, and I couldn’t pass u…

#8
A Tavola

A Tavola

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.5Great

I recall what a watershed moment it was in the #CincyPizza community when A Tavola opened in 2011 - Vine Street had to be shut down to bring in the authentic Neapolitan wood fired oven (carved out of Mount Vesuvius, I be…

#9
Companion Pizza

Companion Pizza

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.5Great

A repeat visit (always a good sign) to this “Neapolitanish” pizza pop-up. I reviewed @companionpizza last year as takeout pizza from Oakley Wines. This time, we tried them for a sit-down meal at @kingpigeoncinci (one of …

#11
Twelve08

Twelve08

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.4Great

Located on 1208 Springfield Pike in stately Wyoming (‘The Brooklyn of Northwest Hamilton County’), Twelve08 is a wood-fired pizzeria that recently celebrated its 4.5 week anniversary. The first thing you notice when you …

#13
L'Industrie Pizzeria

L'Industrie Pizzeria

New York · Neapolitan

8.3Great

An artfully charred New York slice in Williamsburg. L’Industrie serves a New York style pizza with some pronounced Neapolitan influences. It’s distinguished by a particularly thin crust that’s a bit more well done than a…

#14
GoreMade Pizza

GoreMade Pizza

Columbus · Neapolitan

8.0Great

A gorgeous ‘gourmet’ Neapolitan pizzeria in Columbus’s Italian Village neighborhood, that happens to be run by a fellow named Gore. GoreMade/Gourmet prominently features a custom built wood-fired oven, imported from Napl…

#16
Timber Pizza Co

Timber Pizza Co

Washington, DC · Neapolitan

8.0Great

A #WashingtonDC Neapolitan pizza, with Argentine influences. Pictured here is the “Pretty in Pepperoni” with #ronicups and #freshmozzarella added. I tried @timberpizzaco based on the high rating given it by one of my fav…

#17
Delicio

Delicio

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

7.9Worth the Calories

A Neapolitan-ish coal-fired pizza, featuring leopard spotted crust, and located within @hoppinvines. In my experience, coal-fired pizza is pretty much always great. The earliest American pizzerias were coal-fired (like @…

#18
Wildfire Pizza Kitchen

Wildfire Pizza Kitchen

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

7.9Worth the Calories

A pizza truck that frequently pops up around downtown and various breweries/cideries, Wildfire produces 12” wood fired pies. The dough is cold fermented for at least 24 hours and then cooked (quickly) at 900 degrees or s…

#19
Camporosso

Camporosso

Cincinnati · New York

7.8Worth the Calories

An Americanized Neapolitan pizzeria in Ft Mitchell, Camporosso offers two styles: Neapolitan wood-fired pizza and ‘American’ New York-ish gas oven pizza. Pictured is the ‘American’. The crust is more airy/bubbly and Neap…

#20
Joe’s Pizza Napoli

Joe’s Pizza Napoli

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

7.8Worth the Calories

A well-named Neapolitan pizzeria in Milford. We tried three pizzas at Joe’s: the Pepperoni (naturally), the Viva Las Vegas (an award winner from the Vegas Pizza Expo @pizzaexpo, which is quite a big deal), and the Pistac…

#21
Fire Up Pizza

Fire Up Pizza

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

7.7Worth the Calories

This pizza truck regularly pops-up at local breweries, primarily @streetsidebrewery (where they serve on Mondays) & @listermannbrewing (where we caught them). Sidenote: Listermann is an excellent spot to try a small batc…

#23
Bircus

Bircus

Cincinnati · New York

7.5Worth the Calories

A “Goetta Grip” pizza topped with crumbled Goetta sausage & Grippos BBQ potato chips (the world’s greatest potato chip), available at this brewery+circus+Neapolitan pizza mashup. Bircus’s full circus brewery is located …

#30
Little Miami Brewery

Little Miami Brewery

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

6.5Worth the Calories

Straddling the edge of stately Old Milford, just off the Loveland bike trail, and overlooking the Little Miami River is this brick (gas) oven brewery pizzeria. Little Miami’s style might be described a thick heavily-topp…

#33
Zazzy’s Pizza

Zazzy’s PizzaClosed

New York · Neapolitan

9.1Top Tier

One of my all time favorites, located in the West Village, this New York-Neapolitan slice features my favorite pizza characteristics: pepperoni cups & a leopard spotted crust. Both are rare at a time by-the-slice place. …

#34
El Camino Pizza

El Camino PizzaClosed

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.7Great

Since opening in August 2022, College Hill’s El Camino Bakery has been one of our favorite spots in the city for coffee, baked goods, and Gustave Doré inspired decor. More recently, El Camino has started hosting Saturday…

#35
Ocelot Pizza

Ocelot PizzaClosed

Cincinnati · Neapolitan

8.3Great

This might be America’s best-named pizzeria (with the possible exception of @joespizzanyc). Let me explain: Neapolitan pizzaioli strive to achieve a "leopard-spotted crust". That, of course, refers to a pizza crust that …