Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › New Jersey › Sicilian / Square

Quick Take

Brooklyn Square Pizza

7.7New Jersey · Sicilian / Square

New Jersey · Sicilian / Square

cheese-blanketed square slice held on a paper plate, Brooklyn Square Pizza

Brooklyn Square Pizza in New Jersey, rated 7.7/10 (Sicilian / Square).

More to explore

City guideNew Jersey Pizza Reviews Style guideBest Sicilian / Square Pizza

Prince Street PizzaChicago · Sicilian / Square9.1

Corner SliceNew York · Sicilian / Square9

Ace’s PizzaNew York · Sicilian / Square9.4

7.7Worth the Calories

Appears in#5 New Jersey Pizza Reviews #29 Best Sicilian / Square Pizza

City: New Jersey
Style: Sicilian / Square
Address: 265 S New Prospect Rd, Jackson Township, NJ 08527

Map All Reviews

Cincinnati New York Chicago Styles Map Methodology Instagram Contact

The Slice Index · 389 pizzerias · 34 cities · Last updated July 2026

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Method