Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › New York › Coal Fired

Quick Take

Patsy's Pizzeria

7.9New York · East Harlem · Coal Fired Style

Appears in#48 Best Pizza in New York City #12 Best Coal Fired Pizza

Patsy's Pizzeria in New York, rated 7.9/10 (Coal Fired).

7.9Worth the Calories

City: New York
Neighborhood: East Harlem
Style: Coal Fired
Address: 2287 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035

Map All Reviews

More to explore

City guideBest Pizza in New York City Style guideBest Coal Fired Pizza

Rosario’s PizzaNew York · Sicilian / Square8.6

Upside PizzaNew York · Sicilian / Square8.9

L'Industrie PizzeriaNew York · New York Style8.8

Cincinnati New York Chicago Styles Map Methodology Instagram Contact

The Slice Index · 410 pizzerias · 35 cities · Last updated October 2026

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Method