Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Recent Reviews Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › Indianapolis › New York

Rating-only record

Magoo's

Indianapolis · New York

Score recorded for the index; full review text is not yet added.

Keep browsing

City guideMore in Indianapolis Style guideMore New York Same cityBazbeaux Pizza Same styleAndrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria

3.4All Pizza's Good, Right?

City: Indianapolis
Style: New York
Address: 4919 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Map All reviews

The Slice Index · 333 pizzerias · 30 cities · Last updated June 2026