Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › Indianapolis › New York Style

Quick Take

Magoo's

3.4Indianapolis · New York Style

Appears in#4 Indianapolis Pizza Reviews #135 Best New York Style Pizza

Magoo's in Indianapolis, rated 3.4/10 (New York Style).

3.4All Pizza’s Good, Right?

City: Indianapolis
Style: New York Style
Address: 4919 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Map All Reviews

More to explore

City guideIndianapolis Pizza Reviews Style guideBest New York Style Pizza

St Francis ApizzaCincinnati · New York Style9.4

Shackamaxon PizzaPhiladelphia · New York Style9.3

SlicehausNew York · New York Style9.3

Cincinnati New York Chicago Styles Map Methodology Instagram Contact

The Slice Index · 410 pizzerias · 35 cities · Last updated October 2026

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Method