Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › Louisville › Tavern

Quick Take

Fat Jimmy's

3.5Louisville · Middletown · Tavern Style

Appears in#2 Louisville Pizza Reviews #41 Best Tavern Pizza

thin-crust pepperoni pizza cut into square slices, Fat Jimmy's

Fat Jimmy's in Louisville, rated 3.5/10 (Tavern).

3.5All Pizza’s Good, Right?

City: Louisville
Neighborhood: Middletown
Style: Tavern
Address: 12216 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY 40243

Map All Reviews

More to explore

City guideLouisville Pizza Reviews Style guideBest Tavern Pizza

RubinosColumbus · Tavern7.5

Ron’s PizzaDayton · Tavern7.3

Edison's PubCleveland · Tavern6.8

Cincinnati New York Chicago Styles Map Methodology Instagram Contact

The Slice Index · 397 pizzerias · 34 cities · Last updated September 2026

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Method