Skip to content

The Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Methodology

Home › Cincinnati › New York

Quick Take

Shorty's Pizza

5.8Cincinnati · New York Style

Cincinnati · New York Style

Shorty's Pizza in Cincinnati, rated 5.8/10 (New York).

More to explore

City guideBest Pizza in Cincinnati Style guideBest New York Style Pizza

WayfarerCincinnati · Tavern9.5

St Francis ApizzaCincinnati · New York9.4

Andrew Bellucci’s PizzeriaNew York · New York Style9.4

5.8All Pizza’s Good, Right?

Appears in#128 Best Pizza in Cincinnati #165 Best New York Style Pizza

City: Cincinnati
Style: New York
Years Open: 2010–c. 2014
Address: 9585 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati, OH

Map All Reviews

Cincinnati New York Chicago Styles Map Methodology Instagram Contact

The Slice Index · 389 pizzerias · 34 cities · Last updated July 2026

Reviews Rankings Cities Styles Map Method