The Slice IndexThe Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni
City guide

Italy Pizza Reviews

A ranked guide to Italy pizza entries in The Slice Index.

11 entries · 11 open · 0 closed/archive · Open Italy map

puffy blistered-crust margherita with fresh mozzarella pools, L’Antica Pizzeria Da MicheleL’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele9.5Charred slice topped with olives and artichoke, Antico Forno La PieveAntico Forno La Pieve8.5Spongy sfincione square topped with sauteed onions, Bar Cristal S.n.c. di Fortunato Natale & C.Bar Cristal S.n.c. di Fortunato Natale & C.8.3hand holding a folded cheesy square slice, Bella MiaBella Mia7.8Neapolitan pie with mozzarella dollops, capers and basil, GustapizzaGustapizza7.7
Score keyTop Tier · 9.0+Great · 8.0–8.9Worth the Calories · 6.5–7.9All Pizza’s Good, Right? · Below 6.5
#1
puffy blistered-crust margherita with fresh mozzarella pools, L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

Italy · Florence · Neapolitan Style · Apr 2025

9.5Top Tier

I sometimes say: the US has the most innovative chefs but not necessarily the best tomatoes*. Italy has the best tomatoes. So, an Italian pizzeria on top of their game is tough to beat. “Michael’s Ancient Pizzeria” is a legendary Italian restaurant. The Neapolitan original was founded in 1870…

ReviewInstagramMap
#2
Charred slice topped with olives and artichoke, Antico Forno La Pieve

Antico Forno La Pieve

Italy · Arezzo · Roman / Al Taglio, Bakery / Focaccia · Apr 2025

8.5Great

Less traveled than its nearby neighbors Florence and Siena, the eastern Tuscan city of Arezzo boasts impressive masterpieces of its own - namely, Piero della Francesca’s 1452 “Legend of the True Cross” fresco*…

ReviewInstagram PostMap