City guide

Best Pizza in Italy

A ranked guide to Italy pizza entries in The Slice Index.

5 entries · 5 open · 0 closed/archive · Open Italy map

What defines this list

The Italy guide is a compact market view. It currently leans toward Roman / Al Taglio, New York, Neapolitan rather than a single dominant lane.

Highest-rated entries include L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele, Antico Forno La Pieve, Bella Mia. Scores reflect individual visits, so this is a ranked index rather than a crowd-sourced consensus list.

2 full reviews and 0 closed/archive records are included. Rating-only entries remain visible, but full reviews carry the richer editorial context.

#1
L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele

Italy · Florence · Neapolitan · Apr 2025

9.5Top Tier

I sometimes say: the US has the most innovative chefs but not necessarily the best tomatoes*. Italy has the best tomatoes. So, an Italian pizzeria on top of their game is…

#2
Antico Forno La Pieve

Antico Forno La Pieve

Italy · Arezzo · Roman / Al Taglio, Bakery / Focaccia · Apr 2025

8.5Great

Less traveled than its nearby neighbors Florence and Siena, the eastern Tuscan city of Arezzo boasts impressive masterpieces of its own - namely, Piero della Francesca’s…