The Slice IndexThe Slice Indexby Joey Pepperoni
City guide

Dayton Pizza Reviews

A ranked guide to Dayton pizza entries in The Slice Index.

7 entries · 7 open · 0 closed/archive · Open Dayton map

No image
Old Scratch8.0square-cut tavern pie with curled pepperoni cups, Joe’s PizzeriaJoe’s Pizzeria7.7cracker-thin party-cut pie loaded edge-to-edge with pepperoni, Ron’s PizzaRon’s Pizza7.3Pepperoni slice dusted with oregano and red pepper flakes, Flying PizzaFlying Pizza6.1pepperoni pie studded with jalapeños and sausage crumbles, Cassano's Pizza KingCassano's Pizza King5.4
Score keyTop Tier · 9.0+Great · 8.0–8.9Worth the Calories · 6.5–7.9All Pizza’s Good, Right? · Below 6.5
#2
square-cut tavern pie with curled pepperoni cups, Joe’s Pizzeria

Joe’s Pizzeria

Dayton · Dayton · Tavern Style · Oct 2024

7.7Worth the Calories

When I mention “Dayton Style,” the cliché response is always, “It’s an attitude as much as a wardrobe.” And indeed, effortlessly chic is the ultimate Dayton uniform. Elegance is seemingly in their DNA, with a s…

ReviewInstagram PostMap
#3
cracker-thin party-cut pie loaded edge-to-edge with pepperoni, Ron’s Pizza

Ron’s Pizza

Dayton · Miamisburg · Tavern Style · Feb 2025

7.3Worth the Calories

I recently found myself in Miamisburg, Ohio, a picturesque small town full of surprisingly bustling shops just south of Dayton, Ohio (One of my top two Daytons in the greater Cincy megalopolis). Exploring, I en…

ReviewInstagram PostMap
#4
Pepperoni slice dusted with oregano and red pepper flakes, Flying Pizza

Flying Pizza

Dayton · New York Style · Jul 2010

6.1All Pizza’s Good, Right?

Flying Pizza is a small local chain founded by two Sicilian brothers who grew up in Queens. They opened their first Tri-State pizzeria in 1971, which gives the place a more credible New York pedigree…

ReviewMap