Pizza review

Brooklyn DOP

New York · Park Slope · New York · Sep 2025

Brooklyn DOP

@brooklyndop delivers outstanding NY-style pizza with pronounced Neapolitan influence. I assumed it meant “Department of Pizza,” but DOP actually stands for “Denominazione di Origine Protetta” or “Protected Designation of Origin.” Like how Champagne must come from France’s Champagne region, this designation is meant to mark a commitment to authentic Italian ingredients and methods tied to a historic tradition.

Brooklyn DOP began as “pandemic apartment pizzaioli turned brick and mortar.” Perhaps reflecting monklike pandemic dedication to pizza refinement, the pepperoni slice I had here demonstrates exceptionally honed craft. The very thin crust shows impressive charring throughout, with dramatic leopard spotting. It’s perhaps the most charred slice I’ve had without seeming burnt (it’s easy to make a craftless slice that’s more “charred” just leave it in the oven for an hour).

Perfectly baked at 650 degrees (hotter than typical NY but cooler than Neapolitan’s 1,000-degree ovens), these style represents a thoughtful hybrid pizza that maintains NY slice structure with Italian thinness and fire. The smoky character permeates every bite without overwhelming delicate balance. Each element works in harmony - char adds complexity, thin profile maintains integrity, and high-temperature approach creates bubbled edges - separating serious operations from comfortable corner slice shops (no dig at them). For me, a slice paired well with a “My Antonia” Pilsner from @birradelborgo.

This represents pizza craft operating at an elite level. Highly recommended.